16756 Mount Airy Road • Shrewsbury, PA 17361

$469,000 Beds: 3 • Baths: 2 full • Sq. Feet: 1905 • MLS ID: PAYK2097560 • Subdivision: SHREWSBURY • School Dist: SOUTHERN YORK COUNTY
If you long for a farmhouse that stands much as it did in 1880, with original heart-of-pine floors and plaster walls, this may be the property of your dreams. The owners made a deliberate decision to preserve the integrity of this humble farmhouse rather than modernize it beyond recognition. The restored barns and outbuildings offer a rare and authentic glimpse into life as it once was. Historic details abound — Bennington doorknobs, transoms above doorways, and beautifully “combed” wood trim, a trompe l’oeil technique dating to the 1920s. Surfaces show gentle wear from more than a century of living, yet the craftsmanship remains undeniable. This is not a reproduction of history — it is history. The primary bedroom is spacious and airy, featuring nine-foot ceilings and oversized windows that flood the room with natural light. In 2011, a thoughtfully designed nine-by-eleven-foot bathroom was added that blends seamlessly with the home’s history. Historal tiles, patterned plaster walls, wavy glass windows, antique light fixtures, a clawfoot tub, separate shower, and beautiful stained-glass door create a timeless retreat. The eat-in kitchen is both functional and unforgettable. Two focal points anchor the room — a wood-burning fireplace and an antique porcelain sink set into a surround designed by a local craftsman using chestnut beams and barnwood sourced from the property. The kitchen offers abundant storage, including a floor-to-ceiling dish cabinet, spice cabinet, built-in cabinet beneath the stairs and a nine-by-five-foot walk-in pantry. A center island, new stove, and new refrigerator complete the space. It is perfect for a cozy meal by the fire. Adjacent to the kitchen is a bright, versatile room previously used as a formal dining room but spacious enough to serve as a living and dining combination. Two large windows frame views of the pond across the street, and southern exposure fills the space with light. Upstairs two large bedrooms feature generous windows overlooking the pond. A third room has been divided into a small bathroom and a sitting or TV room. A spacious attic provides additional storage. The outbuildings are extraordinary and increasingly rare. A spring house channels an underground spring that feeds the pond across the road. The original stone summer kitchen, complete with a massive fireplace, stands beside the home and creates a magical setting for relaxing in the hot tub on a snowy evening. Its three rooms with separate entrances offer many possibilities. The smokehouse still retains original meat hooks, and a root cellar behind the home once stored provisions. The impressive bank barn, built in the 1880s, features both hand-hewn and machine-hewn beams. A smaller three-bay barn could serve as a garage and it has an enclosed area ideal for chickens. A two-seat outhouse adds to the authenticity. In 2011, the barns were re-sided with one-and-a-half-inch hemlock. The smaller barn received a new tin roof, the bank barn roof was sealed, and the house was re-roofed with lifetime architectural shingles. The grounds are captivating. Flower gardens flourish alongside red and black raspberries and blueberry bushes. Two hills provide excellent sledding. The property is fenced, allowing dogs to roam freely. A one-and-a-half-acre pasture invites grazing or recreation. Follow the stone wall to discover a bright meadow. Paths wind through wooded areas filled with daffodils, crocuses, bluebells, and bee balm. Enjoy outdoor meals, gather around the firepit, and listen to cicadas on summer evenings. You will not know a main road lies nearby. Convenient for commuting to Baltimore and York, with nearby shopping, healthcare, breweries, coffee shops, and access to the hike-and-bike trail, this farmette offers the rare opportunity to live surrounded by history and nature without sacrificing convenience. If you have been searching for authenticity, craftsmanship, and timeless character, this is the one. View this listing at: http://thelancastrian.com/mls=PAYK2097560

Property Features

  • Taxes: $5,547
  • Wooded: Yes
  • Roof Type: Architectural Shingle,Shingle,Metal
  • Exterior: Frame,Blown-In Insulation,Brick,Stick Built,Stone,
  • Parking Notes: 2 Total Parking Spaces
  • Special View Info: Garden/Lawn,Pasture,Scenic Vista,Pond,Trees/Woods,
  • Lot Size: 3.85 Acres
  • Lot Dimensions: 3.85 Acre(S)
  • Heating: Central,Baseboard - Hot Water,Hot Water
  • Fuel Type: Oil
  • Cooling: Window Unit(s)
  • Year Built: 1880
  • Fireplaces: 2
  • Water: Public
  • Sewer: Grinder Pump,Septic Exists
  • Stories: 2.0
  • Number of Rooms: 11
  • Municipality: SHREWSBURY TWP
  • Accessibility: Grab Bars Mod
  • Additional Structures: Above Grade,Below Grade
  • Fencing Description: Board, Fully, Wire, Wood
  • Lot Description: Landscaping, Partly Wooded, Road Frontage, Sloping, Year Round Access
  • Structure Type: Detached
  • Total Garage/Parking Spaces: 2
  • Parking Features: Crushed Stone
  • Pet Restrictions: No Pet Restrictions
  • Appliances: Dryer - Electric,ENERGY STAR Refrigerator,Oven/Range - Electric,Stove,Microwave,Washer
  • Rooms: Dining Room,Primary Bedroom,Bedroom 2,Bedroom 3,Kitchen,Family Room,Foyer,Laundry,Attic,Primary Bathroom,Full Bath
  • SQFT Total Finished: 1905
  • SQFT Above Finished: 1905
  • Exterior: Outbuilding(s),Hot Tub
  • Interior: Attic,Bathroom - Soaking Tub,Bathroom - Walk-In Shower,Built-Ins,Combination Dining/Living,Combination Kitchen/Dining,Dining Area,Entry Level Bedroom,Floor Plan - Traditional,Formal/Separate Dining Room,Kitchen - Country,Kitchen - Eat-In,Kitchen - Island,Kitchen - Table Space,Pantry,Primary Bath(s),Stain/Lead Glass,WhirlPool/HotTub,Wine Storage,Wood Floors
  • Fireplace: Brick,Wood
  • Flooring: Hardwood,Ceramic Tile,Stone,Concrete,Wood
  • Windows: Double Pane,Transom,Wood Frame
  • Electric Description: 200+ Amp Service
  • Utilities: Cable TV Available,Phone Available,Electric Available

Room Sizes

  • Bedroom 2: 17 x 11 Level: Upper 1
  • Family Room: 21 x 14 Level: Upper 1
  • Full Bath: 8 x 6 Level: Upper 1
  • Attic: 17 x 30 Level: Upper 2
  • Bedroom 3: 17 x 11 Level: Upper 1
  • Primary Bathroom: 9 x 11 Level: Main
  • Primary Bedroom: 17 x 11 Level: Main
  • Dining Room: 17 x 11 Level: Main
  • Kitchen: 21 x 11 Level: Main

School Information

  • High School: SUSQUEHANNOCK
  • Middle School: SOUTHERN
  • Elementary School: SHREWSBURY
  • School District: SOUTHERN YORK COUNTY
Printed March 03, 2026


Disclaimer: All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) or information provider(s) shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless. Listing(s) information is provided for consumers personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information on this site was last updated 03/03/2026. The listing information on this page last changed on 03/03/2026. The data relating to real estate for sale on this website comes in part from the Internet Data Exchange program of Delta Media Group MLS (last updated Tue 03/03/2026 12:38:53 AM EST) or Bright MLS (last updated Tue 03/03/2026 12:29:39 AM EST). Real estate listings held by brokerage firms other than Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Homesale Realty may be marked with the Internet Data Exchange logo and detailed information about those properties will include the name of the listing broker(s) when required by the MLS. All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy / DMCA Notice / ADA Accessibility
Federal Housing Equal Opportunity Realtor
Corporate Office - 215 S Centerville Rd. Lancaster, PA 17603
James J Hafer - West Virginia Broker of Record

©2026 BHH Affiliates, LLC. An independently owned and operated franchisee of BHH Affiliates, LLC. Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices and the Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices symbol are registered service marks of Columbia Insurance Company, a Berkshire Hathaway affiliate. Equal Housing Opportunity.


Agent License Information: 
The Andy Esbenshade Team
Licensed in Pennsylvania: Dwight (Andy) Esbenshade, Michael (Mick) Kalata, Melissa Brosey, Gregory Dean, Stephanie Frysinger, Paula Mowrer, Susan Martin
Licensed in Maryland: Gregory Dean
www.TheLancastrian.com 

215 S. Centerville Road, Lancaster, PA 17603
717-393-0100